The Right Slice has earned its reputation as a Kalaheo staple through consistent quality and authentic baking practices. Their commitment to homemade recipes and quality ingredients reflects the care locals expect from a neighborhood bakery.
The Right Slice in Kalaheo, Kauai is a beloved local pie shop and bakery known for its homemade sweet and savory pies. Using quality ingredients and time-honored recipes, they create a rotating selection of pies that have become a local institution on the Garden Isle. Whether you're craving a tropical fruit pie or a classic savory option, The Right Slice delivers comfort food with island charm. Q: What types of pies does The Right Slice offer in Kalaheo, Kauai? A: The menu features both sweet and savory pies, including fruit pies with tropical Hawaiian flavors like guava and lilikoi, as well as classic American pie varieties. Q: Is The Right Slice a good spot for dessert or a meal in Kalaheo? A: Yes — their savory pies make for a satisfying lunch or dinner option, while the dessert pies are a beloved treat for locals and visitors alike. Q: Does The Right Slice offer whole pies to take home? A: Many customers purchase whole pies to enjoy at home or as gifts — calling ahead to order is recommended, especially for popular flavors that may sell out quickly.
Data updated Apr 11, 2026
Pick Bakery in Kalaheo and get rank changes, new openings, and competitor moves every Monday.
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Response |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | The Right Slice | 4.6 | 531 | Tracking |
| #2 | Kauai Kookie Bakery & Kitchen | 4.3 | 551 | Tracking |